We might be into November, but I don’t give up the horror season of Halloween so easily. The time between Halloween and Thanksgiving is a great place to get that final horror fix before the festive and cheerful holiday season starts.

But what about some forgotten horror stories that we don’t usually think about?

Horror has an extensive library, filled not only with familiar names like Dracula and Frankenstein but with dozens of forgotten gems waiting to be rediscovered. These lesser-known horror tales carry a unique charm and a fresh dose of terror—perfect for readers who think they’ve seen it all. Here are some underrated horror classics that deserve a modern audience.

“The Great God Pan” by Arthur Machen (1894)

A pioneer of supernatural horror, Arthur Machen’s The Great God Pan was once considered too shocking for its time. This novella explores dark, forbidden knowledge and the consequences of opening doors to realms best left alone.

Check Out Leif's Books on Amazon

The story follows a young woman who undergoes a mysterious experiment to “see the god Pan,” only to descend into madness and death. Machen’s atmospheric writing and disturbing themes inspired writers like H.P. Lovecraft, who described it as one of the best horror stories ever written. If you like cosmic horror and existential dread, this one’s for you.

“Carmilla” by Joseph Sheridan Le Fanu (1872)

Dracula might be the most famous vampire story, but Carmilla was its eerie predecessor. This gothic novella tells the tale of a young woman who forms an intense friendship with the mysterious, alluring Carmilla, only to discover that her friend might be a bloodthirsty predator. Le Fanu’s work explores themes of love, identity, and fear of the “other” with subtlety and suspense. Carmilla stands as one of the earliest and most intriguing vampire stories, paving the way for later tales of seductive monsters and doomed romance.

“The House on the Borderland” by William Hope Hodgson (1908)

Written decades before Lovecraft, William Hope Hodgson’s The House on the Borderland combines cosmic horror with psychological suspense. The story unfolds as a pair of travelers discover a journal in a crumbling mansion, detailing a man’s descent into terrifying realms beyond human comprehension. From surreal time travel to a fight with nightmarish creatures, this story delivers a unique blend of horror and fantasy. Hodgson’s narrative inspired countless modern tales of haunted houses and alternate dimensions, and it’s a perfect read for fans of the surreal and the uncanny.

“The Willows” by Algernon Blackwood (1907)

Often called one of the finest supernatural horror stories ever written, Algernon Blackwood’s The Willows is a strange, atmospheric tale of two friends on a canoe trip down the Danube River. As they camp in a remote area surrounded by mysterious willows, they encounter forces that defy explanation. This isn’t a story about overt scares but about the slow, creeping horror of the unknown. The Willows has an eerie beauty to it, showing that nature itself can be both sublime and terrifying.

Why These Stories Matter Today

Though often overshadowed by mainstream horror, these forgotten classics continue to inspire modern writers and filmmakers. They remind us that horror doesn’t always need shock and gore to be effective. Sometimes, the best scares come from what’s left unseen, from the eerie atmospheres and subtle terrors that seep into your mind and settle in for the long haul.

If you’re looking for horror with a literary touch, these stories are a goldmine of atmosphere, suspense, and themes that resonate across time. Each offers a unique window into the fears of the past, many of which remain as relevant today as ever.

So, this Halloween, dive into these overlooked tales and experience the eerie echoes of horror’s forgotten voices. Just remember: not all nightmares come with fangs and claws—some creep up on you slowly, lurking in the shadows of your own imagination. Sleep tight!

About Leif J. Erickson

Leif J. Erickson is a science fiction and fantasy author from a small farming community in west central Minnesota. Using his time wisely when he was a farmer, Leif developed many ideas, characters, and storylines to create over fifty unique first drafts and outlines for stories. From his start in a small town school, to college at North Dakota State University, back to his family farm, then to the bright lights of Minneapolis, Minnesota, and back to his small farming town, Leif has always had a love of writing.

When Leif isn’t writing he can be found with his wife hiking in state parks, canoeing local lakes and rivers, exploring local and regional ghost towns, experiencing museums, or simply reading or hanging out with friends and family. Leif draws on the local nature and ecology to find inspiration for his writing while he also asks what’s possible for technology and the human race, weaving them together for amazing stories that will stay with the reader for years to come. Leif looks forward to having many novel and story releases in the years to come.

You can see all of Leif’s Books here: Leif’s Amazon Author Page